The site known as Miami Fort
is no fort at all, and it also is much larger than previously believed – so
large, in fact, that its berms stretch to 3 miles in length, making it twice as
large as any other Native American earthworks in Ohio, and one of the largest in the nation.
Those are discoveries made
this summer by members of UC's Ohio Valley Archaeology Field School
project, who spent weeks working at the site in Hamilton County's
Shawnee Lookout park. What they found actually
offers great insight into the cultural priorities of the Shawnee – the
incredible amounts of human labor that went
into building the earthworks were done for agricultural purposes, not
military.
The earthworks were not a fort, but a water management system of dams
and
canals built to counter the impact of long-term drought.
"This site was
originally described by William Henry Harrison as a great military fort. What
we've discovered this summer is that it is not in any way, shape or form a
military fort," says Ken Tankersley, a UC assistant professor of
anthropology and faculty leader of the field school. A total of 28 students
worked at the site this summer.
What Harrison – who lived in
nearby North Bend, Ohio – interpreted on a hilltop high above the confluence
of the Great Miami and Ohio
rivers to be fortifications with wooden gates are really an ancient irrigation
system that dates back 2,000 years, Tankersley says. The gates were locks and
the berms were terraced dams for controlling water flow.
Harrison's observations of what was on top of the hill also
were only the tip of what was concealed in thick undergrowth. "The
engineering feat is remarkable. There's one place where the dam is almost 200
feet high," describes Tankersley. "It's a remarkable system. The
irrigation system is almost 6 kilometers [3-plus miles] long."
The extent of the Shawnee
Lookout site is nearly twice as large as the site previously thought to be the
largest Native American earthworks in the state, Fort Ancient in Warren County.
Tankersley and his students
set out to learn more about the site as part of UC's summer field school, which
is a highly sought opportunity for students to get hands-on experience at an
archaeological site. In discussing the possibilities of working in Shawnee
Lookout park, Tankersley consulted with UC's department head in anthropology,
Vern Scarborough.
"He's the one who
suggested we might want to consider other possibilities for the site,"
Tankersley says.
"I had a student years
ago who I had been with out at Fort Ancient, and in our discussions, he said that we might
consider looking at (that site) from a water management point of view,"
says Scarborough, who himself studies Mayan cultures and their use of
water. "When you're talking about building on these elevated settings,
that's an important consideration to keep in mind."
To support such a theory, the
field school team went in search of evidence. They found convincing amounts of
it.
What Harrison had described as gates turned out to be fired logs and clay bricks
that were used in damming. On the opposite side of the enclosure, drill cores
were sunk by field school personnel deep into the earth and when extracted,
revealed ponded water sediments and clay minerals, exactly what you ought to
find for an area where water was being captured.
At the highest points that
the earthworks extended to were found raceways for moving water across the
terrain. The raceways originated in areas that contained artesian springs.
Excavation in these areas found limestone rock used to line the areas where the
water was captured, with overflow being channeled into the raceways for
irrigation.
"Where the artesian
springs were found were actually what had been labeled borrow pits, where it
was thought the earth they were using in building these structures came from
these holes," says Tankersley. "But a problem was that there were far
too few of these pits to produce all of the earth that was used in making what
they termed fortifications. Once we cored in and took samples, it became very
clear that these were actually springs feeding these areas. The Shawnee would build these dams and then allow the spring
water to fill these pits, and then they would capture the surface runoff."
Tankersley says there is a
historical reason that makes this elaborate project a logical choice
for the Shawnee – climatic records show the 500-year period leading
up to 500 AD to be an unusually cold and dry era in this region.
Drought would
have been common during this time frame. Native Americans would have
needed
reliable alternatives to supplement the meat that would have been the
staple of
their winter diets, meaning they would have had to cultivate
nut-producing
trees and other crops on their lands.
This drastic change in
interpretation of the structures leads Tankersley to conclude a
re-interpretation of Shawnee culture may be in order.
Two points standout: One is
that the engineering expertise required to conceive of such a massive
irrigation system must have been far greater than what history has
traditionally assigned to Native American groups from that time in history, and
the second is that the cultural priority of engaging in such a massive
undertaking as building these earthworks by hand was done by this culture not
because of military motivations but for a more civil cause.
"It makes you rethink
the stereotype for indigenous people," Tankersley says. "It was
thought they were war-like. But they were sophisticated. As the climate was
changing, they could adapt. Instead of engaging in warfare, these people were
working in harmony."
Tankersley will be taking the
new measurements collected from the Shawnee Lookout site into the lab this fall
and use computer simulation to calculate the amount of dirt that had to have
been moved to create these structures. "We know it has to be a massive
amount," he says.
One more surprise from the
site is who the evidence points to as the likely group that engaged in this
construction. Physical evidence says it probably was the women of the Shawnees.
Moving massive amounts of
dirt would have been done using tumplines that relied on the muscles of the
head and neck. Remains found of Shawnee men from the time period show that they were petite
and graceful, according to Tankersley. The women, on the other hand, were
robust and muscular, and often exhibited developed muscles in the areas on and
around the cranium.
"It amazes me that when
you think of some of the great engineering feats in pre-history, we've always
had this male bias that guys must have been doing this," Tankersley says.
"But the evidence we have at hand turns this around and suggests that it
is actually must have been the women who were doing this work."
More work remains to be done
to further explore the ramifications of what was found this summer. A
question
that clearly is going to have to be addressed is whether the Shawnee
Lookout
site was singular in its purposes, or whether other similar Ohio sites
from this same era such as Fort Ancient and Fort Hill in Highland
County also need to be subjected to historically
reinterpretation.
"The focus of our field
school coming out here was to examine how people adapted to climate
change," Tankersley says. "We knew this was a time period that was
cold and dry, but to find out the true story of this massive engineering feat
was a wonderful discovery."