I wrote this a few days after the scary incident in early April when a five-foot-long gash ripped open atop the fuselage of a Southwest Airlines (SWA) jet while the aircraft was cruising more than six miles in the air. Fortunately, nobody was badly hurt as the pilot never lost control and descended to a safe emergency landing at a nearby military base. Nonetheless, the widely publicized incident sent a shiver down the spines of millions of frequent air travelers like me.
The incident later was traced to a bad riveting job, although it raised fears of metal fatigue stemming from numerous short flights imbedded in SWA’s business model. A similar but worse tear on a 1988 Aloha Airlines flight resulted in scores of injuries and the death of a flight attendant who was sucked out of the airplane while aloft. Aloha specialized in short hops between the Hawaiian Islands, and that accident revealed the until-then-unknown peril of metal fatigue resulting from frequent cabin pressurization. Both accidents occurred with relatively old Boeing 737 planes.
An important business lesson can be learned from the way SWA responded to this crisis. Without being ordered to, SWA immediately grounded all 79 planes it operated of the same class as the afflicted jet. That was about 15 percent of its fleet, and it resulted in the cancellation of hundreds of flights and thousands of delays. The economic hit to SWA and future bookings is unknown at this point, but likely to be substantial. Since SWA flies nothing except Boeing 737 aircraft, questions arise about the long-term consequences for our nation’s heretofore most successful airline company. Nonetheless, the company emphasized passenger safety above all else, and deserves hearty applause for that.
SWA’s plight calls to mind the infamous 1982 episode when seven people in the Chicago area died after taking extra-strength Tylenol capsules that had been filled with cyanide by a still-unconvicted killer. All of us live with the legacy of that crime, which led to a federal law mandating tamper-proof containers for all ingestible products.
The Tylenol tampering clearly was done after the products hit the shelves, so even the sleaziest ambulance chaser would’ve had trouble squeezing money out of the drug’s maker, Johnson & Johnson. Yet instead of dithering and pointing fingers, Johnson & Johnson conducted an immediate product recall spanning the entire country – even though no case of poisoning showed up anywhere except the Chicago area. The recall totaled 31 million bottles, and cost the company more than $100 million. They spent millions more running sensitive TV commercials featuring Johnson & Johnson’s somber CEO explaining their action and expressing sorrow for the victims, even though the company had done absolutely nothing wrong. It remains a textbook example of crisis management taught in business schools throughout the country.
How do you react when one of your jobs goes wrong?
Whether or not it’s your fault is almost beside the point. In most cases, it takes days, weeks or months of forensic investigation to figure out the ultimate cause of a mechanical or management failure. In the here and now, you are held responsible in the eyes of your customer. How a contractor reacts even before knowing all the facts reveals a lot about that contractor’s personal character. It also has a lot to do with the long-term health of the business.
Dithering and finger-pointing is the default position for most business owners when something gets botched. Nobody likes to admit to mistakes, and, as noted, it’s not always clear who’s to blame, especially at first. Yet it’s never good to be perceived as shirking responsibility.
My column in the August 2010 issue, “Prepare for Disaster Now,” covered advice from a crisis management expert on what to do in case of a PR emergency. It was geared to dealing with the news media, but most of the recommendations fit equally well in reacting to customers and other interested parties. Here’s a repeat of some of that advice.
- The first step is to organize an emergency management team
to deal with any potential crisis. In big companies typically this would
include people such as a project superintendent, safety manager, project
manager, HR manager, legal counsel and, of course, a high-ranking executive,
preferably the CEO. Select one of these to be the team leader charged with
responsibility for quick reaction and damage control. The team leader will be
the targeted recipient of all information leading to the emergency and
responsible for disseminating that information to all other emergency team
- Talk to the media. Saying something, no matter how little, is better
than saying nothing. Explaining why you can’t talk more – don’t know all the
facts yet, advice of counsel, etc. – is better than stonewalling. “If you want
your side of the story told, you must tell it,” says crisis management author
Janine Reid. “If you don’t, reporters will get a version elsewhere, such as
from the disgruntled employee who was laid off, or the worker who just
witnessed his best friend getting killed or injured.”
- Avoid “no comment.” Anyone using this statement looks guilty as sin.
If you don’t know the answer, tell the reporter that you don’t know, but will
try to find out. Avoid excuses and explain how you are planning to make things
- Designate one person as the sole spokesperson. In many cases, the
spokesperson would be the company owner/CEO, though in some situations it might
be good to insulate the CEO from media attention. Some CEOs may be too gruff,
inexperienced or for any other reason not the best person to be the public face
of the company, or may be too engaged behind the scenes to devote time to this
- Make sure everyone knows who the spokesperson is. The designated
spokesperson should be the only one authorized to disseminate information to
the outside world, and every other member of the crisis-management team should
clam up and refer all media inquiries to the spokesperson. No information
should be released without being approved by upper
- Don’t cover up. If you find out bad news, bring it up quickly before
someone else does and makes it sound worse than it is. However, first make sure
your information is accurate.
- Tell the truth. This does not mean you have to provide every little
detail or admit to wrongdoing, but lying always comes back to haunt
- Don’t say anything “off the record.” Assume that anything you say
will be made public.
- Emphasize the positive. Point out all the remedial measures taken and what your team is doing to make things right. Talk up any awards or positive recognitions your company has received for professionalism, community work, charitable contributions, etc.
Here’s hoping your problems are magnitudes smaller than the ones that afflicted SWA and Johnson & Johnson.